Skip to main content

Investing Less, Earning More

Could investing $13,000 be better than investing $70,000? In this case, the answer seems to be yes.

In Making Money Made Simple, Noel Whittaker compares two hypothetical investors:

Person 1: Invests $ 1,000 a year from age 18-30.
Person 2: Invests $ 2,000 a year from age 30-65.

You might think that person 2 would be better off, but here's how it goes (in chart form):


Person 1 stops investing at 30, but their investment keeps growing. At that point, person 1's yearly growth is more than person 2's yearly contribution. That's why person 2 never catches up.

Person 1 ends up about $ 150,000 ahead, despite investing about one-fifth of what the person 2 invested.

What if growth isn't so good?

These calculations assume 10% growth. What if it isn't that high?

Fair point. I've run the numbers at lower rates of growth. At 9%, person 1 is still better off. At 8% it's close, and person 2 comes out slightly ahead. But that's not really the point.

One investment is one-fifth the size of the other (smaller contributions and a shorter time). The fact that this is anywhere near a close finish is mind-boggling.

Person 1 has earnt about 50 times their money back. For Person 2 it's less than 8 times. That's the benefit of starting early.

It's the tortoise and the hare

If you measure from when each person starts investing, person 2 does go up more quickly. But person 1 is further ahead because they started earlier and just kept going.

For instance, after 35 years of investing person 2 has about half a million. Person 1 had just $200,000 after 35 years of investing. It's a slower initial rate (like the tortoise) but because of the earlier start, they still had another twelve years of growth to come.

The maths of compound growth means that the bulk of the earnings come in the later years. The earlier the start, the more productive those later years can be.

What if I'm older?

If you're in your 30s or 40s, you might be cursing your luck. But the principle still holds for you - better to start now than wait until 55.

If you're 45 or older, perhaps show this concept to your teenager - if they're interested in making hundreds of thousands of dollars.

If you're a teenager or young adult, then congratulations. You have the most important asset. Time.

What else?

See more of my finance articles or get the monthly email for more stuff like this in the future.

Comments

  1. My mind is always blown when I see these comparisons! I'd love to see another version with actual ages taken out and replaced with "# of years of investing". Less disheartening for those of us who didn't start at 18. :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hello Michelle.
      Yeah it's tricky. The purpose was to powerfully illustrate the specific example given in the book I'd read. I hoped converting the numbers into a timeline would graphically show that an early investor is always better off (at any point on the journey).
      I considered leaving off the numbers entirely, introducing a third person who doesn't start until 50 (to give heart to the 30 year-old reader) or having a 30-year old starter who catches up by investing even more. But none of these seemed as impactful and clear as the original point - so I stuck with that.
      I thought of making the horizontal axis "years of investing" but thought that would be confusing (as it would end at 47). A great deal of my point is that the early investor does just 13 years of (active) investing and never adds again - that compound growth does so much of the work.
      Having said all that I hope that the 30-something can still see that person 2 still gets a very juicy outcome, from a relatively tiny annual saving.
      I still have plenty more finance ideas up my sleeve for future articles, so I hope you've subscribed :) As someone who's definitely older than 18, I can assure you I'm very much thinking of people who are further along the journey, even if this article was most impactful for people too young to have ever seen a fax machine ;)

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The real cost of owning a car

It's been about 10 years since I've owned a car. My wife doesn't own one either. "You must save a lot in petrol" That's one of the frequent reactions when someone discovers we don't own a car. "Of course, but it's just the tip of the iceberg" is the usual theme of my reply. Many people I've talked to just aren't fully aware of the real cost of owning a car. Or even that there are six different costs of owning a car. Six? Really? Yes. Occasionally a work colleague or friend will boast their car only costs $X per week. Of course it turns out only some factors have been counted. Sometimes it's just petrol alone. To some people, that feels like the only cost they pay each week. Why does this matter? You might be questioning the need for a second car in the household (or even having one at all). Or you might just be choosing which car to get next. Either way, to make an informed decision we need proper information. So let's look at...

How much super will we have?

Will we be OK in old age? How much will we have? One of the great things about living in Australia is superannuation. Our employers are required to pay into an investment account for our retirement. In recent times, my wife and I have been in several conversations with friends who are wondering (or worried) if their balance will be enough. That's what inspired this article. Great question It's a great question to ask, especially around the age of 35 to 40. At that point, old age is less of a distant abstract concept. It's becoming a medium-term reality. At 35 the number of years of living off super is possibly more than half of your remaining years. At 40 you may consider yourself about half way through your working life. Looking at your balance, it's easy to think that twice that balance may not be enough.  Read on, because I have good news for you. It's better than you might think As I've mentioned in earlier posts, compound growth means the investment grows f...

Less Clutter More Cash - now available

Do you feel like you have too much stuff? Is your home full of things you never use? Would you like to swap them for cash? We did My wife and I have sold more than 550 items online as we downsize and we've learnt a bit along the way. I've put some of our best tips into this handy ebook. I hope you can use these tips so you too can have less clutter and more cash. Enter your email address below to receive the book for free. Less Clutter More Cash Get my new ebook for free. PS. This will subscribe to the But Wait There's Less email list, so you'll know when the new updated version of the book is available. You can unsubscribe at any time.