Skip to main content

Early access to super? Only as a last resort

To stimulate the economy during these strange times the Australian government is allowing people to raid their superannuation accounts.

They'll let eligible people take out $10,000 this financial year (before 30 June) and a second $10,000 after 1 July.

Why "early super access" is a bad idea

While there may be an incredibly small number of people who could benefit from this, for the vast majority it seems to me to be a terrible idea. Here's why...

1. You'll pay a 37% "desperation tax"

Superannuation money is invested in the sharemarket (among other things). For some it's 100% in the shares, for others it's a bit less.

This morning the Australian sharemarket was at 4,564. Back on 20 Feb it was 7255. That's a drop of 37.1%.

Basically, shares are going cheap. So if you own shares (and you do, through your superannuation) this is a terrible time to cash them in because you'll get a rather low amount of cash for them.

If you've got $20k in super, a month ago that was worth $31,800. In the future it will be worth $31,800 again - and more. But if you cash it in now, you don't get that extra $11,800 - it's gone.

That's like paying a 37% tax on any money you take out through this scheme. Ouch!

2. You'll be hurting a 70-year-old (you).

There's a reason we have our money in superannuation. It's a great investment which sets us up for our elderly years.

It's amazing how much money grows over a long time-span. Australian superannuation averages 8.3% per year.

Leaving the $20k in your superannuation has massive payoffs down the track. How massive? That depends on your age now. At 8.3% here's how much better off would you be when you're 70 (if you leave the 20k in now).


That's a lot of money to give up for $20k now.

What else can I do?

There's a variety of people reading this. Some may be in extreme trouble while others might just be looking to add a quick $20k to their bank account. What I'm saying is to explore other options first.

People on government payments are getting temporary increases and special one-off payments. State governments are looking at assistance for renters, banks are already offering homeowners a pause in your repayments.

Can you borrow money from your parents? Is there a charity near you that provides cheap or free food? Do you have unwanted items that you could sell online? The average household has thousands of dollars worth. Here's my free guide for selling your stuff online.

What if I absolutely have to?

As I said at the beginning, there's a few people whose individual situation means this is a necessary step. Fair enough.

Once things are back to normal it's probably a good idea to save some extra money into your super to make up for the loss. You'll still take a hit from the "desperation tax" I described earlier, but hopefully you can still make great use of the high growth of superannuation to set you up for your elderly years.

Big disclaimer

This is a summary on my general thoughts on the subject, supplemented with some maths. It is not financial advice, and does not take into account your individual situation. Please evaluate you own circumstances and seek your own financial advice.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Latte Factor

For the first time ever I'm reviewing a novel. Latte Factor is a short story  - around 120 pages - and is equal parts of inspirational story and financial education. The combination of the two is quite rare, and done quite nicely. The story is about Zoey Daniels, associate editor for a travel magazine. Although she's never been outside the USA  - "a travel editor who's never travelled". She struggles with money and is considering a higher-paying job at the company her friend Jessica works for. The job would provide more income, but would also be more stressful and demanding. She already has a nightmare about being on an increasingly-fast treadmill that she struggles to stay on. Her current boss Barbara - aware only of the money situation - suggests she talk to Henry at the coffee shop. This peculiar suggestion is where Zoey's life begins to turn a corner. Spoiler Alert Being a book of fiction, I don't want to spoil the story for you. It's a book you ca...

Dollars and Sense

Dan Ariely is an expert on human psychology and decisions. His book  Dollars and Sense is focussed on how to avoid "money mishaps" . That can include paying too much for something; buying something that doesn't provide value; or in some cases not buying something that we really should buy. We can be better spenders of money by avoiding money mishaps. We can get more value for our money - or get the same value for less money. So what are the mishaps? Here are some highlights. Opportunity Cost This is the idea of thinking about what else we could do with money - and whether that's better value.  In one experiment, people were given the option of (A) a $1000 stereo or (B) a $700 stereo and $300 cash. People chose option A. Then people where given the option of (A) a $1000 stereo or (B) a $700 stereo and $300 worth of music. Now they chose option B. In the first choice, people gave up the $300 because they wanted the more expensive stereo. But when forced to think of some...

Monopoly, money and you

One of the most well-known board games can also be a great way to learn about money and investing - according to this book. Perhaps one way to teach kids (and maybe ourselves) about finance is to play a board game. In so many ways, the game parallels our own financial life - and we can practice financial decision-making without losing any real money. Is monopoly like life? Yes and no. We manage our cash, negotiate, make deals, make choices, go through tough times, make investments, pay tax and reap rewards. To do well we have to make investments. It's very hard to win just by collecting $200 each time you pass go. There are rules, and wise moves. The better we know them, the better we do. However, in real life, you can win without forcing others into bankruptcy. Principles that work in the game and life Diversify. You might have hotels on the two most expensive properties on the board, but if no-one lands on them, you still might lose. Investments have a price and a value. They are...