Is private health insurance a waste of money?

Buying things we don't need. It makes us poorer, so we have to work more just to break even. Often we'd be better off not buying.

The biggest household expense, other than our house, is health / medical costs.

Is private health insurance worth it?

Finance expert Scott Pape (The Barefoot Investor) says in many cases the answer is no. He reckons if you're under 31, or earn under $90,000 ($180,000 for couples) you're probably better off without it.

Why? Australia has "one of the best public health systems on the planet" that's already paid for; so you may as well use that. (Note: This may be a different story in the USA and other countries). The exception is if you're over 30 and a high income earner.

What's wage got to do with it?

Health insurance is one product the government punishes you for not buying. If you're a high income earner you'll be taxed more if you don't buy some. If you decide to buy some later in life (later than 30) then you'll pay an extra fee on top of normal premiums - whatever your income.

Despite all these punitive measures, it still may not be worth it. Try this interactive calculator to see the pros and cons for your situation.

From an advertising perspective

ABC's comedy/advertising show Gruen did a health episode. Most of the chat was about the psychology of how companies advertise - particularly to young people who generally don't need the product. "In the past year 250,000 people have ditched health insurance. The majority of them are under 34", states host Wil Anderson.

Todd Sampson on Gruen discussing private health insurance

"They can do math and they've worked it out", explains panelist Todd Sampson. The insurance companies "don't want you to use too much. They work off the 30% rule. So if you pay $1000 for your fee you get roughly $300 back a year - and $700 goes straight to profit."

PS. Make up your own mind about your situation, but do think about whether you need it and what the reasons are. According to stats, it's the second biggest single cost after housing. You may also want to see my post on how to save on housing.

Comments

How to waste a year's wages

A friend recently asked me why it is that so many people (on good incomes) are struggling to save. Often the big three money areas are housing, transport and food. In one sense these are necessary items. But what we spend on them is often way more than necessary. I crunched some numbers on how much extra my wife and I could spend on these things - if for some reason we wanted to burn our money. 1. Housing Our apartment is fairly nice, but also cost-effective. I've mentioned how choosing it saves us $1,800 per year , compared to a similar one we saw. The high end of 2-bedroom apartments in our suburb is $305 per week more than our apartment. Not $305 per week. $305 per week more than ours is. I cannot get over that. Sure it's new and modern-looking, but that's a lot of money. It's an extra $15,860 per year above what we pay. 2. Transport The Australian Automobile Association lists the costs of owning and running a car. It includes many often-overlooked c...

How much super will we have?

Will we be OK in old age? How much will we have? One of the great things about living in Australia is superannuation. Our employers are required to pay into an investment account for our retirement. In recent times, my wife and I have been in several conversations with friends who are wondering (or worried) if their balance will be enough. That's what inspired this article. Great question It's a great question to ask, especially around the age of 35 to 40. At that point, old age is less of a distant abstract concept. It's becoming a medium-term reality. At 35 the number of years of living off super is possibly more than half of your remaining years. At 40 you may consider yourself about half way through your working life. Looking at your balance, it's easy to think that twice that balance may not be enough. Read on, because I have good news for you. It's better than you might think As I've mentioned in earlier posts, compound growth means the investment grows f...

Why millionaires don't "feel" rich

We're wealthier than ever - so why don't we feel like it? Australia has gone almost three decades without recession. The stock market recently hit a record high. Our wages are record highs. Home loan rates are at record lows. We live in one of the richest countries in the world at the richest point in history. So what's wrong? Comparison Wealth is relative. So what do we compare to? Where we expect to be? "When your wages growth is only 2 or 3 per cent, you don't feel as well-off as when it's going up 10 per cent. That's that nominal distortion that people often suffer from" , says economist Shane Oliver, and that "expectations have grown a lot faster than reality." We're earning more than last year, but we want even more. So compared to our imaginary situation, we see ourselves as worse off. What we see around us? Shane Oliver again. "If you think about it - Australians today are a lot wealthier. They're living far ric...

But wait... there's less!

Search This Blog