Is private health insurance a waste of money?

Buying things we don't need. It makes us poorer, so we have to work more just to break even. Often we'd be better off not buying.

The biggest household expense, other than our house, is health / medical costs.

Is private health insurance worth it?

Finance expert Scott Pape (The Barefoot Investor) says in many cases the answer is no. He reckons if you're under 31, or earn under $90,000 ($180,000 for couples) you're probably better off without it.

Why? Australia has "one of the best public health systems on the planet" that's already paid for; so you may as well use that. (Note: This may be a different story in the USA and other countries). The exception is if you're over 30 and a high income earner.

What's wage got to do with it?

Health insurance is one product the government punishes you for not buying. If you're a high income earner you'll be taxed more if you don't buy some. If you decide to buy some later in life (later than 30) then you'll pay an extra fee on top of normal premiums - whatever your income.

Despite all these punitive measures, it still may not be worth it. Try this interactive calculator to see the pros and cons for your situation.

From an advertising perspective

ABC's comedy/advertising show Gruen did a health episode. Most of the chat was about the psychology of how companies advertise - particularly to young people who generally don't need the product. "In the past year 250,000 people have ditched health insurance. The majority of them are under 34", states host Wil Anderson.

Todd Sampson on Gruen discussing private health insurance

"They can do math and they've worked it out", explains panelist Todd Sampson. The insurance companies "don't want you to use too much. They work off the 30% rule. So if you pay $1000 for your fee you get roughly $300 back a year - and $700 goes straight to profit."

PS. Make up your own mind about your situation, but do think about whether you need it and what the reasons are. According to stats, it's the second biggest single cost after housing. You may also want to see my post on how to save on housing.

Comments

Simple phone

I get my fair share of teasing for still using a Nokia phone. So I feel quite vindicated that someone has now invented a new non-smartphone . It's pitched for those who want a decluttered life. Instead of features, its selling points are things like "reclaim a little quietude from the constant intrusions of technology", "no internet connection, no app store and definitely no camera for taking selfies". One quote from the article said "as smartphones get bigger and bulkier, there is a place for something small and simplified, without all the functions." That kind of statement resonates with me. Not just for phones, but for so many areas of life - including the houses we live in.

Why own a car, when you can go get?

That's the slogan of one company providing an alternative to car ownership. Here's our experience with them. Why not just have our own car? Another time I'll write a full post about that, but suffice to say that car ownership is a pain in the neck. The servicing, the maintenance, the repairs, the parking, the traffic, the registration, the insurance, the cleaning... For my wife and I, about 98% of our transport needs can be done on foot, by bike, by train, bus or ferry. Maybe 99% if you include rideshare. So we choose to avoid the pain (and cost) of car ownership. However, car use (I think of it separately from car ownership) can be handy in certain situations. We had one of those situations last weekend. Here's how it went. Booking a car My wife signed up for GoGet , and booked the car online for the time window she needed it. As a first-timer, she received her little membership card in the mail. On the day of the booking, GoGet sent her a reminder email about 20 minut...

The Latte Factor

For the first time ever I'm reviewing a novel. Latte Factor is a short story - around 120 pages - and is equal parts of inspirational story and financial education. The combination of the two is quite rare, and done quite nicely. The story is about Zoey Daniels, associate editor for a travel magazine. Although she's never been outside the USA - "a travel editor who's never travelled". She struggles with money and is considering a higher-paying job at the company her friend Jessica works for. The job would provide more income, but would also be more stressful and demanding. She already has a nightmare about being on an increasingly-fast treadmill that she struggles to stay on. Her current boss Barbara - aware only of the money situation - suggests she talk to Henry at the coffee shop. This peculiar suggestion is where Zoey's life begins to turn a corner. Spoiler Alert Being a book of fiction, I don't want to spoil the story for you. It's a book you ca...

But wait... there's less!

Search This Blog